FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What Gross Domestic Suffering measures, how it works as an alternative to GDP, and how you can get involved.

The basics

What is Gross Domestic Suffering?

Gross Domestic Suffering (GDS) is an open index that ranks countries by the preventable suffering their people and animals experience. It combines 12 indicators in six pillars (illness, gender and sexual discrimination, violence, unfreedom, deprivation and animal suffering) into one score from 0 to 100. Higher means more suffering.

Is GDS an alternative to GDP?

Yes. GDS is an alternative to GDP for judging national success. GDP measures what a country produces; GDS measures the suffering that production fails to prevent. We see it as a complement to GDP, not a replacement for economic statistics. Compare GDS with other alternatives to GDP.

What are the limitations of GDP?

GDP ignores unpaid and household work, counts harmful spending (pollution clean-up, prisons, treating preventable disease) as growth, hides inequality, ignores the depletion of nature, and says nothing about illness, despair or suffering. Read the 8 limitations of GDP.

How is GDS different from the misery index?

The economic misery index, created by Arthur Okun, adds the inflation rate to the unemployment rate. GDS measures suffering directly across illness, gender and sexual discrimination, violence, unfreedom, deprivation and animal suffering, rather than through two macroeconomic proxies. Learn more about the misery index.

Is GDS the opposite of Gross National Happiness?

They are complementary. Bhutan's Gross National Happiness and the World Happiness Report ask how good life is. GDS asks how much preventable suffering remains, on the view that ending misery is the most urgent and most widely shared goal of public policy.

The methodology

Which indicators does GDS use?

The framework has 12 indicators in six pillars, each framed as suffering. Illness: premature adult death, infant mortality, the share of life lived in ill health, and deaths from alcohol and drug use disorders. Gender and sexual discrimination: the UNDP Gender Inequality Index (85%) and anti-LGBTI laws (15%). Violence: homicides, war deaths and suicides. Unfreedom: prisoners plus people in modern slavery, and overwork. Deprivation: undernourishment, extreme poverty and forced displacement. Animal suffering: how weakly the law protects farm animals. Read the full methods.

Where does the data come from?

From public, internationally comparable primary sources: the World Health Organization, World Bank, UN Development Programme, UN Office on Drugs and Crime, Uppsala Conflict Data Program, World Prison Brief, Walk Free, the UN Food and Agriculture Organization, International Labour Organization, UNHCR, World Animal Protection and Our World in Data. The full dataset and code are open on GitHub.

Why does GDS include animal suffering?

Tens of billions of animals are raised and killed each year in conditions shaped by national laws and markets. Suffering does not stop at the species line. Animal suffering is one of the six pillars of every GDS score. It measures how animals are treated, not how many are eaten, using World Animal Protection's grades for farm-animal protection laws.

How are the indicators weighted?

Each indicator is scaled from 0 to 100 against fixed goalposts that never change between years, so scores can be compared across countries and over time. The six pillars are weighted equally. We also test 1,000 random weightings and publish the range of ranks each country could receive.

Where does the United States rank?

In 2023 the United States ranked 61st of 188 countries, behind countries with a fraction of its GDP, such as China, Albania, Kazakhstan and Türkiye. Its worst pillars are animal suffering, illness, driven by overdose and alcohol deaths, and unfreedom, with 872 people per 100,000 in prison or modern slavery.

Which countries have the least suffering?

In 2023, the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, Austria and Switzerland had the lowest suffering scores. Somalia, Haiti, the Central African Republic, South Sudan and Burkina Faso had the highest.

The project

Who runs Gross Domestic Suffering?

GDS is a research project of Elton University, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit university based in the United States. Read more about the project.

When will the full rankings be published?

A revised, fully documented methodology and open dataset are in development. Follow the project on GitHub to be notified of releases.

Can I contribute or suggest an indicator?

Yes. The methodology and code are open. You can open an issue on GitHub to suggest an indicator, a data source or a correction.

Can I use GDS data in my research or reporting?

Yes. Please cite Gross Domestic Suffering, Elton University, and the version of the index you used. Once the dataset is published, we plan to release it under an open license.

Can I study these questions at Elton University?

Yes. Elton University offers a master's in Heterodox Economics, taught one-on-one by expert professors, fully online.

Still have a question? Ask us on GitHub.